Virtual Appointment
Back11/26/2024
(Pros and Cons!)
Thanksgiving: the holiday of gratitude, good food, and a house full of loved ones. It might seem like the perfect occasion to pop the question—but is it? Let’s break down the pros and cons of proposing on Thanksgiving so you can decide if this is the moment to ask the biggest question of your life.
Thanksgiving is all about giving thanks, making it a day brimming with warm, heartfelt emotions. It’s a perfect time to tell your partner just how grateful you are for them—and what better way to do that than with a diamond in hand? Proposing in this context could make your gesture even more meaningful and memorable. Every year, Thanksgiving would become a celebration of love, gratitude, and that unforgettable "yes."
Thanksgiving often means being surrounded by family and close friends, which can make your proposal even more special. If your partner is close with their family, having them present for the big moment can add extra layers of joy and celebration. Plus, you’ve got a built-in cheering section ready to celebrate afterward.
Example: Propose just before dessert, so the entire family can toast your engagement over pumpkin pie. Bonus points if someone has a camera ready to capture the reactions!
Thanksgiving has all the makings of a romantic setting: glowing candles, cozy vibes, and tables decked with seasonal beauty. It’s the kind of ambiance wedding planners dream of recreating. Use the natural charm of the holiday to your advantage—it’s practically designed for memorable moments.
Example: If there’s a fireplace roaring, propose in front of it, perhaps with a warm blanket and a mug of hot cider nearby. Or, take a brisk walk in the autumn air before surprising your partner with a heartfelt question among the fallen leaves.
If you propose on Thanksgiving, you’ve already got a ready-made party happening! No need to plan a separate engagement celebration—everyone’s already gathered, and the food is on the table. Just add a few champagne glasses to the mix, and you’re good to go
Thanksgiving can be chaotic, with cooking, hosting, and general family antics keeping everyone on their toes. Proposing during this whirlwind might feel rushed or even overlooked in the hustle and bustle of the day.
Example: You don’t want to drop to one knee only to have someone shout, “The gravy’s burning!” Consider timing your proposal for a calm moment—perhaps during a quiet walk after dinner or just before everyone sits down to eat.
While Thanksgiving often brings families together, it might not include all the people who matter most to your partner. If they’d want close friends or other key family members to be part of the big moment, proposing on Thanksgiving could feel incomplete.
Solution: Think about who’s at the table. If the absence of someone important might take away from the joy, it might be worth waiting for a different occasion.
Proposing in front of a crowd can be intimidating. If your partner isn’t a fan of public displays of affection, asking the question in front of family might be overwhelming—or worse, awkward. You don’t want your romantic gesture to feel like a stage performance.
Solution: If you’re unsure how they’d feel about a public proposal, keep it intimate. You can still propose on Thanksgiving but do it in private and share the good news with the family afterward.
If it feels right, embrace the festive atmosphere and let the gratitude flow. Just remember: no matter when or where you propose, it’s your love and thoughtfulness that will truly make the moment unforgettable!